Pizzaiolo by Brothers, since 1970

Open daily from 11 am

Midland Park’s family pizzeria, since 1970.

Brick-oven pizza, homemade pasta and Mom’s Sicilian recipes. Order pickup or delivery right here.

The Pizzaiolo by Brothers storefront and sign on Godwin Ave
Penne alla vodka, made at Pizzaiolo by Brothers
Penne alla vodka
Grandma pie, made at Pizzaiolo by Brothers
Grandma pie
Hot honey pepperoni, made at Pizzaiolo by Brothers
Hot honey pepperoni
Burrata, made at Pizzaiolo by Brothers
Burrata
Chicken parm, made at Pizzaiolo by Brothers
Chicken parm
Al crudo, made at Pizzaiolo by Brothers
Al crudo
Cannoli, made at Pizzaiolo by Brothers
Cannoli

Order direct from our kitchen

No app, no markup. Pick your dishes, choose pickup or delivery, done.

⏱ Pickup in about 20 min📍 85 Godwin Ave

Reviews

What our neighbors say

4.1 569 Google reviews

★ 4.6 on DoorDash · 2,000+ ratingsFamily-owned since 1970

  • Marcella Abbate

    Aug 2026 · Google review

    ★★★★★

    “…very good food, special pizza and very special italian plates for every taste. Roberto is top 🔝 and I love all family. They are so much gentle with customers.”

  • Melissa B.

    Google review

    “Only 3 days in advance we reached out to see if they could provide pizza for our 100-person party. Not only did they accommodate, they were professional and made it special for our day. Delivery was on time to the minute. We ordered 60 pies, and they were all hot, fresh, crispy and a big hit.”

  • Kathy

    Jun 2025 · Grubhub review

    ★★★★★

    “Food was amazing as usual. Delivery was perfect”

  • Erika

    Nov 2024 · Grubhub review

    ★★★★★

    “Fabulous every time I order. Large portions!”

  • Des KF

    2024 · Google review

    ★★★★★

    “When I ate the sandwich, it was very good… I had a good experience.”

  • Mark

    Aug 2024 · Grubhub review

    ★★★★★

    “Great food, great delivery”

  • Colleen

    Jan 2024 · Grubhub review

    ★★★★★

    “Food is consistently excellent. Chicken Parmesan portion is huge and the right amount of cheese and sauce. Salads are given extra love when creating.”

  • Danielle

    Jan 2024 · Grubhub review

    ★★★★★

    “We live a little far from the restaurant and are so thrilled to have it delivered!”

  • Frank Filippelli

    2023 · Google review

    ★★★★★

    “This is a fine place with a beautiful atmosphere… the focaccia bread is pretty good and the Barata cheese is amazing.”

Real reviews from Google and Grubhub, shortened where marked “…”.

Catering & parties

Feeding a crowd? Leave it to us.

From office lunches to a 100-guest engagement party, we cater every occasion with our signature Southern Italian dishes, and we’ll shape the menu to your taste and budget.

  • Host it here. Two private rooms, each for up to 40 guests.
  • Or anywhere you like. Off-site catering arrives with chafing dishes, sternos and racks, set up for you. Servers available.
  • Easy return. Drop the equipment back at Pizzaiolo, or we’ll send a driver to pick it up.
  • Packages for 8–12, 13–20, 21–30 and 31–40 guests. Half tray feeds 6–8, full tray 12–14.

Talk to Anthony: 201-444-4944 · or order office catering on ezCater

Catering inquiry

Tell us about your event and we’ll put a menu together.

Two of the Pizzaiolo brothers in the kitchen The Pizzaiolo by Brothers sign Our dining room with the yellow polka-dot banquette

Our story

One family, one oven, since 1970

In 1970 Nino Mazzola, a mason who had helped build the World Trade Center, bought a small pizzeria in Midland Park. Nino made the pies out front while his wife Anna waited tables and ran the kitchen. That was Brothers Pizza.

Their son Anthony grew up at that oven and learned his mother’s Sicilian cooking: simple dishes, quality ingredients. His brother-in-law Roberto Mannino, born and raised in Sicily, brought the Sicilian-style pie. In 2012 the family opened Pizzaiolo by Brothers, a rustic farmhouse dining room with brick-lined ovens.

Many of Anna’s recipes haven’t changed in over 50 years. Neither has the welcome.

Visit us

Hours & location

Pizzaiolo by Brothers
85 Godwin Ave (Midland Park Shopping Center)
Midland Park, NJ 07432
Monday11 am – 9 pm
Tuesday11 am – 9 pm
Wednesday11 am – 9 pm
Thursday11 am – 9 pm
Friday11 am – 10 pm
Saturday11 am – 9:30 pm
Sunday11 am – 9 pm

BYOB. Outdoor dining April through October.

Pizzaiolo by Brothers storefront at 85 Godwin Ave

Fresh out of the oven, every day

Specials, behind-the-scenes and the pies we can’t stop making.